The 8 Best Boutique Hotels in Nantucket [2023]

Nantucket is an island that can be found off the coastline of Cape Cod in Massachusetts. Known for its whaling history and for being an elegant summer destination, Nantucket is a beautiful place to discover.

The charming cobblestoned streets in town are full of upscale boutiques, gourmet restaurants, and eye-catching churches. To discover Nantucket in style, guests should stay overnight at one of the luxurious boutique hotels on the island.

The Best Boutique Hotels in Nantucket

21 Broad

Price: From $169

21 Broad brings urban chic to the island of Nantucket while still preserving local charm. This boutique hotel can be found in the downtown historic district. It is full of indulgent modern luxuries in an ultra-trendy setting.

21 Broad features a stylish guest lounge, expansive outdoor deck with a fire pit, and personalized concierge services. Each room at this boutique hotel has a modern design with extremely plush linens and blackout shades to ensure rest.

Designer bath products are provided by Lather, and guests can enjoy waffle kimono robes, a Keurig coffee maker, a fridge, and a flat-screen smart TV. Every day, a gourmet breakfast of curated small plates is served to guests.

Accommodation options at the 21 Broad include petite, king, and queen versions. Some add waterfront views as an extra treat.

Cliff Lodge

Price: From $161

Originally built in 1771 as the comfortable home of a whaling master, Cliff Lodge has been a part of Nantucket history for many generations. Surrounded by breathtaking views, the lodge is known for providing both elegance and comfort.

It offers personalized service, complimentary Wi-Fi, daily breakfasts served in baskets, en suite bathrooms in every room, and complimentary on-site parking. Guests are only 10 minutes away from town and the docks for the ferry. A highlight of the property is its pre-Revolutionary War architecture features.

Original art by local creators adorns every space. Each room has a memory foam mattress, Matouk towels and bed linens, Frette beach towels, and a flat-screen TV. Designer bath products are provided by Grown Alchemist. Accommodation options have a wide range of sizes and features to cater to the needs of every guest.

Greydon House

Price: From $190

Nantucket’s highly-stylish Greydon House is full of history and classic-style rooms. These unique features were designed by the famous Roman and Williams architecture practice. Greydon House is an established name in Nantucket, offering an overgrown-style English-inspired garden.

The on-site restaurant borrows a sense of whimsy from far-away Venice. Guests are treated to complimentary coffee from the Handlebar Café when they wake. Complimentary beach amenities are provided, including tote bags and a Bluetooth speaker from Bose. Guests can choose their preferred designer bath amenities from the Beauty Bar.

The hotel allows guests complimentary use of Fujifilm INSTAX Mini 11 cameras to immortalize all the incredible sights. This stylish boutique experience includes Portuguese hand-painted tiles in each bathroom.

Each room has deluxe bath products from Acqua di Parma. Greydon House is only a few steps away from the Whaling Museum and the docks.

Hotel Pippa

Price: From $179

Hotel Pippa is a stylish boutique hotel in Nantucket, seamlessly blending timeless elegance with modern innovation and island flair. Each space in the Pippa is carefully curated with refined architectural details and vibrant pops of color.

Thought-provoking artworks adorn every area of the hotel. This is not a typical quaint island retreat but one that pushes the envelope while still remaining at the height of sophistication. The midcentury influence on the design is full of style.

Accommodation options at the Hotel Pippa include traditional guest rooms and 2-bedroom suites. Each room has a Dyson hairdryer, cozy bathrobe, luxurious bath products from Davines Momo, a flat-screen TV, and complimentary Wi-Fi.

The hotel provides complimentary beach chairs, coolers, and beach towels from Matouk. There is an on-site bar and garden lounge. Complimentary breakfast is served daily.

Jared Coffin House

Price: From $155

The Jared Coffin House is one of the oldest hotels on the island. This historic location is full of elegance and charm, complemented by modern conveniences. Initially built as a private mansion in the classic style, this landmark hotel has been providing visitors with excellent service and luxury since its redesign in 1961.

The Jared Coffin House offers guests access to the neighboring White Elephant Spa. It also provides complimentary bottled water, parking, Wi-Fi, and priority bicycles. Year-round accommodations and a courtesy car service are also available.

Each room includes luxurious furnishings, comfortable bathrobes, crisp linens, flat-screen TV, and cozy slippers. It’s a perfect location for romantic getaways, family trips, and friend adventures.

Accommodation options are spread between the Main House and the Daniel Webster House for an extra private boutique experience.

The Nantucket Hotel

Price: From $324

The Nantucket Hotel blends the comforts of a bed and breakfast with the luxurious amenities of a resort option. The resort first opened as a hotel in 1891 and has since been a staple on the island. After many iterations, the location was lovingly restored in 2012 and renamed to its current version, the Nantucket.

Accommodation options include traditional guest rooms along with suites of up to 2 bedrooms and private cottages. There are also 3- and 4-bedroom premium suites for group or family trips.

Room amenities include a flat-panel cable TV with DVD player, cozy robes, Frette linens, an iHome unit, and signature custom-blended bath products. Guests can also have an in-room safe, under-counter fridge, and coffee maker. The hotel provides beach chairs and beach towels for extra convenience.

The Wauwinet

Price: From $250

The Wauwinet is a gorgeous island retreat in Nantucket that overlooks the bay and the splendor of the Atlantic Ocean. This oceanfront location features historic architecture and plenty of luxurious local charm.

Accommodation options at the Wauwinet include stylish guest rooms and private cottage suites. The Wauwinet includes access to private beaches, complimentary shuttle rides to the ferry, a town shuttle, kayaks and paddleboards, bikes, and personalized concierge service. There is an on-site fine dining restaurant, as well as a tennis court.

A pre-arrival concierge can help guests organize every detail of their trip to their specifications before they ever get to the island. The Wauwinet also puts its own boat, the Wauwinet Lady, at the disposal of guests.

Morning risers are treated to fresh coffee and baked goods. In the summer, beach gear is provided to guests. Upon departure, the hotel sends guests off with a goody bag.

White Elephant Hotel

Price: From $295

The White Elephant Hotel is an established Nantucket landmark. This chic waterfront resort is full of island charm and luxury. Its harborside location gives guests easy access to the Brant Point Lighthouse, the Children’s Beach, and Nantucket Town.

There is a heated outdoor pool with private cabanas, and guests can use the hotel’s complimentary bikes to explore the island. There is a top-tier on-site spa and a restaurant. Pre-arrival concierge service is available, as well as personalized attention during the stay. There is a gift shop and a business center, as well as a fitness center.

The White Elephant spreads over various buildings, each offering different accommodation options. Each of them features modern amenities, amazing views, premium linens, and local art pieces. The contemporary coastal decor includes stylish furnishings that blend in with the surroundings.

Final Thoughts

Despite its small size and its apparent isolation, the island of Nantucket is a fascinating location. Visitors can explore the Whaling Museum, the 3 lighthouses, the many attractions on Main Street, and the excellent fishing opportunities.