The 11 Best Boutique Hotels in the Florida Keys [2023]

The Florida Keys are a hugely popular string of tropical islands frequently chosen as beach destinations. They stretch from southern Florida across the Gulf of Mexico and are known for their amazing sights and holiday experiences.

It comes as no surprise that these glamour-filled locations offer plenty of stylish boutique hotels for visitors to enjoy.

The Best Boutique Hotels in Florida Keys

Baker’s Cay Resort Key Largo

Price: From $652

The ultra-luxurious Baker’s Cay Resort can be found in Key Largo. Taking full advantage of the stunning nature surrounding it, this boutique resort offers amazing views of sunsets and a private beach for guests to enjoy.

This is a place designed for full relaxation, where life can be savored at a slow pace. The design is nature-inspired, with rich textures and stylish décor. There are open-air corridors to fully enjoy the breeze, as well as private balconies and sustainable products.

Accommodation options include hammock view rooms over the forest, waterfront rooms with views over Florida Bay, and partial waterfront guest rooms and suites. There are also sprawling premium waterfront suites.

Each room has a coffee maker, custom-tiled shower, flat-screen TV, and all-natural Lather bath products that feature custom Baker’s Cay cosmetics.

Bungalows Key Largo

Price: From $1,049

The highly luxurious Bungalows Key Largo resort is the only all-inclusive adults-only destination in Florida. Guests over 21 can enjoy this sumptuous boutique experience. Found within a botanical garden and surrounded by 1,000 feet of ocean shoreline, the resort’s proximity to the Gulf Stream makes it an overall success.

Accommodation options include waterfront bungalows, along with garden bungalows with king or 2 queen versions. Each bungalow has an outdoor soaking tub and a private veranda. The waterfront options include a private porch with Adirondack chairs.

In-room amenities include deluxe linens, a double pillow-top mattress, a steamer, a flat-screen smart TV, a Keurig coffee maker, a beverage cooler, a microwave, a ceiling fan, and a work desk. The spa-style bathroom has a rain shower with bathrobes.

There is a Zen Garden Spa, along with a Fitness Tiki Hut and a sunset pool with a Jacuzzi.

Hot Tip: Learn about the best beaches in Florida, including the Florida Keys, in our detailed guide.

Cheeca Lodge & Spa

Price: From $349

Located in the sportfishing capital of the world, Islamorada, the Cheeca Lodge & Spa features 27 acres of beautiful gardens, a palm-tree-lined beach, and oceanfront access. There is an on-site 9-hole par 3 golf course, several pools designed for adult and family use, 3 first-class restaurants, and even the environmental Camp Cheeca program for kids.

There is also a spa and a fully-equipped fitness studio. The oceanfront Tiki Bar and the 25 South poolside oasis offer a great, relaxing atmosphere. Guests have unlimited use of fishing and watersports equipment.

Accommodation options include guest rooms and suites with resort views, lagoon views, oceanfront views, and private casitas. In-room coffee and tea are provided, along with bottled water and complimentary Wi-Fi.

Guests have access to 6 lighted sports courts, a private fishing pier, and boat docking accommodations.

H2O Suites

Price: From $599

A refined adults-only hotel in Key West, H2O Suites offers residential-style accommodation to all guests over 25. Each suite has either a private balcony or patio with a plunge pool. The rooftop pool and bar offer amazing views over Key West, and all the best attractions are only steps away, with Duval Street right next to the hotel.

This boutique experience is a luxurious oasis with a resort atmosphere and plenty of privacy in the heart of Old Town. All the suites have a private bedroom, a separate living area with a comfortable lounging sofa, and a fully-stocked wet bar.

Each bathroom has a spa-style design with Italian marble accents and pampering glass rainfall showers. Soft bathrobes are provided, along with slippers and 2 large-screen TVs. Each suite has an opulent king-size bed.

Isla Bella Beach Resort

Price: From $479

Found on a beach in Marathon, the Isla Bella Beach Resort is a stunning modern luxury resort with incredible ocean views from every room. There is a beach bar, as well as 5 pools and an on-site fine dining restaurant.

This boutique resort is a glamorous oasis with a sea-themed blue and white color palette throughout every space. Contemporary art, stand-out prints, modern furnishings, and opulent bathrooms all contribute to making the Isla Bella a stand-out choice. Accommodation options include 1- and 2-bedroom guestrooms, along with suites.

Some of them have oceanfront terraces, while others have private beachfront walk-outs. There are king and queen options, along with walk-in rainfall showers, deep soaking tubs, and furnished outdoor living areas for extra opulent pampering sessions. Deluxe bath products are provided by Molton Brown.

La Te Da

Price: From $320

La Te Da can be found in Key West, in what was once the Perez Residence, dating back to 1892. Famous for its piano bar, this charming boutique hotel is a part of Key West’s history and continues to provide delightful accommodation options.

Guest rooms and suites at La Te Da feature a bed with a Sealy Posturepedic mattress, a large safe, a minifridge, a flat-screen TV, wicker furnishings, and tropical color palettes. There are custom stripped-back fabrics done in a cabana-style to add to the beach holiday atmosphere.

Some of the rooms have a shared porch, and all of them are adorned with tropical-themed art pieces. Couples or friends traveling together can book relevant adjoining options to have private deck access. The pool is available exclusively for guests to unwind.

Hot Tip: The Overseas Highway from Miami to Key West was named one of our best road trips in the U.S. Check out suggested stops for your itinerary!

Little Palm Island Resort

Price: From $3,090

Found just off the Florida Keys coastline, guests can find the Little Palm Island Resort, a fully private island full of tropical flora and fauna. This adults-only retreat is made from thatched-roof bungalows that are styled according to the British West Indies standard.

Old-world charm and modern convenience meet at the resort, with an indoor and outdoor spa, top-rated cuisine, and an on-shore reception and lounge. This private island oasis features vaulted ceilings, outdoor showers, breathtaking views, and sumptuous spaces.

The top-rated spa promises an island sanctuary full of ground-breaking wellness treatments. Wi-Fi is available on the island, but guests are discouraged from keeping their devices on loud. Peace and privacy are a priority on this island getaway. The only TV on the whole island can be found in the Great Room.

The Marquesa Hotel

Price: From $395

Found in the historic Old Town of Key West, The Marquesa Hotel sprawls across 2 locations next to each other that create a private resort atmosphere. Guests have access to 3 pools and wonderful gardens that are perfect for relaxing.

The on-site Café Marquesa offers excellent dining options. This boutique hotel is right next to the many shopping, dining, and drinking opportunities on Duval Street. This exclusive and intimate retreat provides a peaceful escape that is still in the heart of town.

Accommodation options at The Marquesa Hotel include award-winning guest rooms and suites that preserve some of the 19th-century flair that characterizes the location. Each of these rooms is beautifully appointed, with a modern bathroom, cable TV, bathrobes, fridge, safe, and make-up mirror. The hotel offers complimentary coffee and tea service to guests, along with free Wi-Fi.

Oceans Edge Key West

Price: From $303

Located right next to Key West, on Stock Island, the Oceans Edge Resort & Marina is full of Florida Keys charm. This boutique option offers guests a luxurious private getaway with 20 acres of palm tree-filled grounds, 6 swimming pools, and a full-service marina. An hourly shuttle is provided with access to downtown Key West.

There is an on-site restaurant and café, as well as a poolside bar. In addition, dedicated concierge services are available, including the organization of personalized eco cruises and golf tournaments.

Guest rooms and suites at the Oceans Edge include a furnished oceanfront balcony, deluxe bedding made by Connoisseur, a coffee maker, a minibar, luxury furnishings and accents, a Serta mattress, and a flat-screen LG TV. The bathroom features a glass-enclosed walk-in shower, Grand royal towels, Boca Terry bathrobes, and custom bath amenities from the special Key West collection.

Pier House Resort & Spa

Price: From $649

Initially built in 1967, the Pier House Resort & Spa is a shining part of Key West history. It now offers custom design accommodations full of island flair and tropical beauty. The on-site bars and dining options make it a world-class private getaway.

The Pier House offers guests access to an exclusive white-sand beach that is reserved solely for their use. There is an outdoor swimming pool with a poolside bar, an on-site health spa, a fitness center, and a whirlpool hot tub.

A concierge and a doorman are there to help with the needs of each guest, and there is also a dry cleaning service available. Rooms and suites include coffee service, bathrobes, a safe, beach and pool towels, and umbrellas. There is a Tesla charging station on-site for extra convenience.

Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

Price: From $323

A beautiful oceanfront resort with vintage charm found in Islamorada, the Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina is a popular Florida Keys choice. The Postcard Inn has been open since 1951 and continues to offer world-class service and amenities.

The resort features a walk-in beach, signature cocktails, plenty of water sports activities, and 24/7 relaxation and entertainment. The island-style rooms feature crisp white linens, distressed wood details, and nautical accents.

Sunshine and breeze fill every space. In-room amenities include a flat-screen TV, pillow-top bed, deluxe linens, a private furnished balcony, a minifridge, a coffee maker, a safe, and designer bath products.

There are king and queen guest rooms, oceanfront rooms, and oceanfront suites. Private cottages with oceanfront or resort views are also available for groups traveling together or guests seeking more space for a fully relaxing experience.

Final Thoughts

The Florida Keys have incredible views, world-class beaches, and tantalizing beaches. There are internationally top-rated sport fishing opportunities and unbeatable water activities like scuba diving and snorkeling. Boating fans will have much to enjoy, too, while the beach and cocktail lovers will thrive no matter which Key they choose to visit.