Why I’m Not Signing Up for Free Elite Status With American Airlines

If you weren’t aware, American Airlines is offering targeted members the easiest path to status: Instant Status Pass.

Right now, I could click on a button in my email and get automatic Platinum Pro status with AA, the airline’s second-highest tier … but here’s why I’m not signing up.

American Airlines Instant Status Pass Offer

Earlier this month, American Airlines sent targeted emails to Hyatt elite members offering an elite status trial. Those with Globalist or Explorist status in World of Hyatt can sign up for 4 months of Platinum Pro status with American Airlines — with just the click of a button! Too easy.

This offer requires registering by September 5, 2024. To keep my newfound American Airlines elite status, I need to start earning Loyalty Points. That’s the sole metric for AAdvantage status, whether you’re earning it the traditional way or through a promotion like this one.

AAdvantage Platinum Pro Benefits

If you received this offer, you may be wondering what Platinum Pro status is worth.

There are several key benefits as a Platinum Pro member, including 80% bonus earnings on spending with American Airlines, priority boarding and check-in, complimentary checked bags on AA flights, priority bag delivery at your destination, same-day standby and flight change benefits, plus upgrades on flights within North America.

You also get access to preferred seats without paying for them and can buy an Admirals Club lounge membership at a discount.

Why This Offer Isn’t Worth It for Me

I won’t pretend there isn’t any value to AA’s Platinum Pro status — there certainly is. If you fly with AA semiregularly, getting a more comfortable seat or receiving your bags first at your destination can be great benefits.

It’s that “if you fly with AA” part … that’s my issue. My Instant Status Pass offer includes 4 months complimentary elite status. I would only get these benefits on 1 upcoming itinerary, and that’s why I’m not clicking on the button to enroll for the offer.

To be clear, I have 3 bookings with American Airlines in the next few months. However, I booked 2 of them using British Airways Executive Club Avios. Thus, my AA account isn’t listed on those bookings, so I wouldn’t get any AA status-related benefits on those flights.

Could I sign up for this temporary offer and enjoy perks on a single booking? Sure, I could. I have a paid flight departing John Wayne Airport in Orange County, CA (SNA) — my home airport — and heading to Chicago (ORD) with a connection in Phoenix (PHX). I could get a premium seat at no charge, and maybe I would get an upgrade to first class, though that’s unlikely. Premium seats out of SNA almost always sell out, and upgrades are extremely rare on AA, Delta, or United. Plus, I have no need to check a bag on this trip, so the benefits I would enjoy are quite limited.

Plus, I tend to be conservative with offers like this if I don’t think I’d get value out of them, even if they’re “free.” What if another offer comes along in 6 months but says, “You’re ineligible if you got complimentary status in the past 24 months”? Why lock myself out of a offer I might use by enrolling in an offer that doesn’t give me much?

Final Thoughts

I have an email offer to sign up for complimentary Platinum Pro status with American Airlines, getting 4 months of status with no effort. However, I’m not signing up, as I don’t think I’d get much value out of the offer, based on my upcoming travel plans.

The offer ends on September 5, so I’ve got a few weeks to see if my travel plans change. Just in case, I won’t delete the email until September 4.