Why I Broke My Rule of Not Booking Through an Online Travel Agent

I just booked a flight using an OTA for the first time since grad school. As someone who has spent the last 7 years warning people against doing exactly that, this is a big deal.

The reason for this brief moment of hypocrisy? I found a fare from Japan to Europe in July, flying Japan Airlines’ new business class, for less than the price of an economy ticket. So yes, I caved.

This seemed like the perfect opportunity to discuss the pros and cons of booking through an OTA — and explain in more detail why I felt confident breaking my travel-booking rule.

Why I Typically Avoid Booking Flights Through OTAs

As a high school and college student, my go-to for booking flights was Skyscanner. It was easy to search for my preferred route, click the link to the cheapest website selling the ticket, and book (probably with a debit card) without a care in the world. This was fine when I was taking short European hops with nothing but a backpack and a tenner in my pocket.

When I moved to London, started my first big-boy job, and dipped my toes into the world of points and miles, everything changed. Ironically, it was working as a travel agent at Flight Centre that really showed me why avoiding online (and in-person) travel agents is usually the safer move, but that’s a story for another day.

The biggest issue is this: When you book through an OTA, the airline often isn’t responsible for helping you after the booking is made. Oftentimes, even using the PNR (reservation number) to log in to the airline’s booking portal results in an error message asking you to contact the third-party site instead.

That means things like seat selection, baggage, or flight changes can quickly turn into a frustrating back-and-forth. This can also turn into a back-and-forth, where the airline tells you to contact the OTA, and the OTA tells you to contact the airline.

If that’s not enough to dissuade you, there’s a chance that booking via an OTA could mean you might not be acknowledged by your preferred frequent flyer program. We’ve seen versions of this before, including when American Airlines limited earnings on some third-party bookings, only to reverse it.

I’ve never found myself in such a predicament, but I have heard enough stories from regretful people who have over the years. That said, I recently found myself willing to risk all. I came across a one-way Japan Airlines business class ticket from Seoul (ICN) to Paris (CDG), connecting in Tokyo, for just $1,600, which caused me to risk it all (with some due diligence, of course).

How This Japan Airlines Fare Made Me Break My Rule

I’ve wanted to fly JAL’s new business class on the Airbus A350-1000 since it launched in 2024 (I can’t believe it’s been over 2 years). I’m visiting Japan for the first time this summer, and I was determined to factor in flying this new seat.

I wasn’t using points for this trip — I’m saving those for a few bigger redemptions later — and my travel dates in late July weren’t flexible. And keep in mind that the only cities in Europe where JAL currently sends its A350S are London (LHR) and Paris (CDG). That combination made finding a deal a lot harder. I was going to have my work cut out for me.

I headed straight to Google Flights — my go-to search engine — and started my research.

How I Found the Deal

With fares for nonstops from Haneda (HND) to Paris starting at $3,200 and to London from $4,000, those were out of the question. The next trick was checking routes that departed from other Asian cities, connected in Tokyo, and flew JAL’s Airbus A350 to either London or Paris. This is a tried-and-tested method I’ve used for years to score discounted business class tickets.

I planned to visit Seoul for the first time before heading back to Europe, so I set Seoul as my departure city and changed the airline filter to show only JAL options. That’s when Google Flights started showing one-way fares for $1,600. Considering that it was half the cost of the first nonstop options, things were starting to look up.

The routing would have me fly from Seoul (ICN) to Tokyo Narita (NRT) with an overnight layover, then depart the next morning from Tokyo Haneda (HND). That kind of inconvenience probably influenced the much lower fare.

I then selected the flight and saw that booking with Trip.com was the only way to get this price. Feeling both curious and dubious, I followed the link and was presented with the following 3 options for booking.

At that point, I slowed down and started double-checking everything.

Why I Felt Comfortable Booking Through an OTA (This Time)

I first wanted to make sure that the long-haul leg to Europe was definitely in business class and not a mistake fare. It clearly stated economy for the first leg and business for the second, and I was perfectly happy to fly in economy for the short hop from Seoul to Tokyo. The increased baggage allowance of 3 bags also solidified this as a legitimate business class booking.

Then I noticed the recommended option included free cancellation. This meant I’d be able to change or cancel the ticket for free, even after confirming and paying. The fact that it was only £4 ($5.30) more than the nonrefundable option was an even bigger shock. Even when booking business class directly with an airline, there’s often a premium charge for a fully refundable or flexible fare.

As convinced as I was beginning to feel that Trip.com was the real deal, I needed a little more reassurance. The final stage of the booking process allowed me to choose and confirm my seats — for free! Once I was presented with the seat map of the Japan Airlines A350-1000 and could select window seat 9A, I knew I was in.

It was happening: I was about to spend $1,600 on a business class ticket using an OTA.

Booking Experience and Final Checks

I used my U.K. version of the Platinum Card^® from American Express to pay for the ticket.

BEST LOUNGE CARD

Terms Apply / Rates & Fees

Platinum Card^® from American Express

U.P. Rating 

The rating for this card has been determined by our own industry experts who know the ins and outs of credit card products. Bonuses, rewards as well as rates and fees are all taken into account. Compensation from the issuer does not affect our rating. We only recommend products we either use ourselves or endorse.

The Amex Platinum reigns supreme for luxury travel, offering the best airport lounge access plus generous statement credits, and complimentary elite status.

Apply Now(at Amex's secure site)

Apply With Confidence

Know if you're approved with no credit score impact

If you're approved and accept this Card, your credit score may be impacted.

Platinum Card^® from American Express

The Amex Platinum reigns supreme for luxury travel, offering the best airport lounge access plus generous statement credits, and complimentary elite status.

Welcome Offer

You may be eligible for as high as 175,000 Membership Rewards^® points after you spend $12,000 in eligible purchases on your new Card in your first 6 months of Card Membership. Welcome offers vary and you may not be eligible for an offer. Apply to know if you’re approved and find out your exact welcome offer amount – all with no credit score impact. If you’re approved and choose to accept the Card, your score may be impacted.  

As High As 175,000 Points. Find Out Your Offer.

UP's Offer Valuation*:

Up to $3,850

Annual Fee

$895

APR

See Pay Over Time APR

Credit Recommended

Upgraded Points credit ranges are a variation of FICO^® Score 8, one of many types of credit scores lenders may use when considering your credit card application.

Good to Excellent

Why We Like This Card

When it comes to cards that offer top-notch benefits, you’d be hard-pressed to find a better card out there than the Platinum Card^® from American Express.

Make no mistake — the Amex Platinum card is a premium card with a premium price tag. With amazing benefits like best-in-class airport lounge access, hotel elite status, and tremendous value in annual statement credits, it can easily prove to be one of the most lucrative cards in your wallet year after year.

 

 

Pros & Cons

Pros

• The best airport lounge access out of any card (by far) — enjoy access to over 1,550 worldwide lounges, including the luxurious Amex Centurion Lounges, Priority Pass lounges (enrollment required), Plaza Premium Lounges, and many more!
• 5x points per dollar spent on flights purchased directly with the airline or with AmexTravel.com (up to $500,000 per year)
• 5x points per dollar spent on prepaid hotels booked with AmexTravel.com
• Annual and monthly statement credits upon enrollment (airline credit, Uber Cash and Uber One, Resy, lululemon credit, streaming credit, prepaid hotel credit on eligible stays, Walmart+ credit, CLEAR+ credit, and Equinox credit)
• TSA PreCheck or Global Entry credit
• Access to American Express Fine Hotels and Resorts and Amex International Airline Program
• Access to Amex transfer partners
• No foreign transaction fees (rates and fees)

 

Cons

• $895 annual fee (rates and fees)
• Airline credit does not cover airfare (only incidentals like checked bags)

 

 

Read Full Review

Card Highlights

• You may be eligible for as high as 175,000 Membership Rewards^® points after you spend $12,000 in eligible purchases on your new Card in your first 6 months of Card Membership. Welcome offers vary and you may not be eligible for an offer. Apply to know if you’re approved and find out your exact welcome offer amount – all with no credit score impact. If you’re approved and choose to accept the Card, your score may be impacted.
• Get more for your travels with 5X Membership Rewards^® points on all flights and prepaid hotel bookings through American Express Travel^®, including Fine Hotels + Resorts^® and The Hotel Collection bookings. You earn 5X points on flights purchased directly from airlines or through American Express Travel^® on up to $500,000 on these purchases per calendar year.
• With over 1,550 airport lounges - more than any other credit card company on the market* - enjoy the benefits of the Global Lounge Collection^®, over $850 of annual value, with access to Centurion Lounges, 10 complimentary Delta Sky Club^® visits when flying on an eligible Delta flight (subject to visit limitations), Priority Pass Select membership (enrollment required), and other select partner lounges.* As of 07/2025.
• $200 Uber Cash + $120 Uber One Credit: With the Platinum Card^® you can receive $15 in Uber Cash each month plus a bonus $20 in December when you add your Platinum Card^® to your Uber account to use on rides and orders in the U.S when you select an Amex Card for your transaction. Plus, when you use the Platinum Card^® to pay for an auto-renewing Uber One membership, you can get up to $120 in statement credits each calendar year. Terms apply.
• $300 Digital Entertainment Credit: Experience the latest shows, news and recipes. Get up to $25 in statement credits each month when you use your Platinum Card^® for eligible purchases on Disney+, a Disney+ bundle, ESPN streaming services, Hulu, The New York Times, Paramount+, Peacock, The Wall Street Journal, YouTube Premium, and YouTube TV when you purchase directly from one or more of the providers. Enrollment required.
• $600 Hotel Credit: Get up to $300 in statement credits semi-annually on prepaid Fine Hotels + Resorts^® or The Hotel Collection* bookings through American Express Travel^® using the Platinum Card^®. *The Hotel Collection requires a minimum two-night stay.
• $400 Resy Credit + Platinum Nights by Resy: Get up to $100 in statement credits each quarter when you use the Platinum Card^® to make eligible purchases with Resy, including dining purchases at U.S. Resy restaurants. Enrollment required. Plus, with Platinum Nights by Resy, you can get special access to reservations on select nights at participating in demand Resy restaurants with the Platinum Card^®. Simply add your eligible Card to your Resy profile to book and discover Platinum Nights reservations near you.
• $209 CLEAR+ Credit: CLEAR+ helps get you to your gate faster by using your face to verify you are you at 55+ airports nationwide. You can cover the cost of a CLEAR+ Membership* with up to $209 in statement credits per calendar year after you pay for CLEAR+ with your Platinum Card^®. *Excluding any applicable taxes and fees. Subject to auto-renewal.
• $200 Airline Fee Credit: Select one qualifying airline and then receive up to $200 in statement credits per calendar year when incidental fees, such as checked bags and in-flight refreshments, are charged by the airline to the Platinum Card^® Account. American Express relies on airlines to submit the correct information on airline transactions to identify incidental fee purchases. If you do not see a credit for a qualifying incidental purchase on your eligible Card after 8 weeks, simply call the number on the back of your Card. Qualifying airlines are subject to change. See terms & conditions for more details.
• Start your vacation sooner, and keep it going longer. When you book Fine Hotels + Resorts^® through American Express Travel^®, enjoy noon check-in, when available, and guaranteed 4PM check-out.
• $300 lululemon Credit: Enjoy up to $75 in statement credits each quarter when you use the Platinum Card^® for eligible purchases at U.S. lululemon retail stores (excluding outlets) and lululemon.com. That’s up to $300 in statement credits each calendar year. Enrollment required.
• $155 Walmart+ Credit: Receive a statement credit* for one monthly Walmart+ membership (subject to auto-renewal) after you pay for Walmart+ each month with the Platinum Card^®.* Up to $12.95 plus applicable local sales tax. Plus Ups not eligible.
• Whenever you need us, we're here. Our Member Services team will ensure you are taken care of. From lost Card replacement to statement questions, we are available to help 24/7.
• $895 annual fee.
• Terms Apply.

Financial Snapshot

• APR: See Pay Over Time APR
• Foreign Transaction Fees: None

Rewards Center

American Express Membership Rewards

 

 

Once I’d confirmed, I received an email stating that the payment had been received but that the tickets hadn’t been issued, which could take up to 2 hours. This was followed by a statement that any price increase would be covered by Trip.com, which I also did not expect.

About 15 minutes later, I received a confirmation email from Trip.com that my booking was complete, including a JAL booking reference and ticket number. That was all the reassurance I needed to know I’d just booked a legitimate fare and could start getting excited about flying one of the best business class seats in the world!

As a final check, I entered the booking reference or ticket number in JAL’s booking management section on its website. An error message informed me that I needed to contact the entity I booked with to make any changes, which is pretty standard for third-party flight bookings.

All that’s left now is showing up at Seoul (ICN) at the end of July to see whether I will indeed be flying JAL’s new business class from Haneda to Paris.

Final Thoughts

The combination of little flexibility, a bucket-list opportunity, and heavy due diligence led me to book JAL’s business class through an OTA. To be honest, it still doesn’t feel real.

Breaking this rule was not a rash decision, and if it hadn’t been for the free cancellation option, the ability to choose a seat, and being given a JAL ticket number, I would have probably let this one slide.

Would I do it again? I’ll wait and see what happens at the airport in July before I can answer this. However, if a similar opportunity presented itself in the future, I can’t see why I wouldn’t put my trust in an OTA again. That said, I’ll still always advise booking directly with the airline where possible.