American Airlines: Economy vs Basic Economy – What Are The Differences?

Full Disclosure: We may be financially compensated when you click on links to credit card products from our advertising partners, such as American Express, Chase, Citi & Capital One. Opinions and product recommendations on this site are ours alone, and have not been influenced, reviewed or approved by the issuer. See our Advertiser Disclosure for more details. Thanks!

The infamous “Basic Economy” can be a daunting ticket purchase for some flyers who may not know what is or isn’t included.

Introduced to combat against low-cost carriers, American Airlines’ Basic Economy fare class does come with many restrictions — and knowing them is important to having a good experience onboard.

Here’s what we’re going to explore:

  • What is Basic Economy?
  • How does it differ from regular economy?
  • What are the restrictions? What are the benefits?
  • How does it compare to other carriers?

What Is Basic Economy?

Basic Economy is the cheapest fare class onboard American Airlines — a no-frills experience that includes some standard onboard amenities, but with many restrictions that will tempt plenty of flyers to avoid this option.

On American, Basic Economy books into the “B” fare class, so it’s pretty easy to remember. But B fares are not offered on every single itinerary, so Basic Economy might not be available on your specific flight. American routinely looks at pricing, destinations, and demand to determine where and when offering Basic Economy fares will make sense.

Some routes — particularly those to domestic leisure destinations — almost always have Basic Economy. Some routes never do, and some routes have limited B fare tickets. In some cases, you can find Basic Economy fares at the last minute, even on the same day of departure.

When booking on AA.com or with any online travel agency (like Orbitz or Kayak), passengers will see a notice that informs them of any restrictions on the ticket prior to payment. This warning is important and has been subject to debate — it’s clearly cautioning travelers from booking a Basic fare, and enticing them to book a regular economy ticket that will come with more perks and benefits.

If you find a Basic Economy ticket, the price difference between regular economy can be variable (and surprising): you may see a difference of $10, or a difference of several hundred dollars! I’ve seen plenty of circumstances where the Basic fare was in the $50 range, while the next lowest regular fare was in the $400s.

(This can be confusing, since one of the goals of Basic Economy is to encourage flyers to bump up their fare to regular economy. But such a high fare discrepancy would make it difficult for many travelers. We’ll leave this strange pricing decision up to the airlines!)

Bottom Line: Basic Economy books into the “B” fare class when you look for flights on AA.com, but it might not always be available. If you find a Basic Economy ticket, make sure you understand the restrictions and difference in cost between regular economy.

Why Was Basic Economy Introduced?

Most low-cost carriers segment their ticket offerings to reduce the ticket price displayed to the public — things like seat assignments, checked bags, onboard service, and upgrades will all come with separate fees. By removing these offerings from the economy fare, passengers can add them in as they see fit, resulting in a lower price appearing when a prospective passenger searches for a fare.

Many travelers may not want to pay extra for the ancillary services offered, and are likely to stick with the most no-frills option to save some money. When they do need additional services or products, they pay for them, creating additional revenue for the airline.

American followed suit after Delta and United, who had already introduced their own Basic Economy products. Because American was in the midst of a merger, it wasn’t practical to introduce the Basic product any sooner than they did.

Bottom Line: Basic Economy gives passengers more pricing options while creating more revenue opportunity for the airline.

What Are the Restrictions of American Airlines Basic Economy?

Of course, with a cheaper fare comes more restrictions, so it’s really important to understand the differentiations between a Basic Economy ticket and a regular economy ticket.

Baggage Allowance

First, with American Airlines Basic Economy, carry-on bags ARE allowed on the plane: 1 in the overhead bin and 1 under the seat in front of you. This is the same as all other economy class fares. As long as you carry on what would be considered a normal bag that fits in the sizer, you should be fine.

That said, as you’ll read on below, your chances of available room on the plane decrease dramatically since you’ll be boarding with Group 9 on a Basic Economy ticket — so while you do have the ability to take bags onboard, space availability may dictate otherwise.

Ticket Changes

Second, no flight change requests or refunds will be allowed. You won’t be able to do any same-day change, you won’t be able to standby for a later or earlier flight, and you won’t be able to change your flight in advance under most circumstances — even as an AAdvantage elite.

When you book a Basic Economy fare, you’re booking a fully inflexible ticket — so choose exactly the flight you want at exactly the right time. This can especially be critical to business travelers who rely on ticket changes survive on business trips (though the lack of change ability would probably be okay with most leisure travelers).

American Airlines Main Cabin
Main Cabin (Economy). Image courtesy of aa.com.

Boarding & Priority Access

Priority Access is not available for any Basic Economy passengers, even if you’re willing to pay for it separately. The exceptions to this are AAdvantage elites who will still board in their respective groups: Executive Platinum in Group 2, Platinum Pro and Platinum in Group 3, and Gold in Group 4. And AAdvantage credit card holders will still board in Group 5, after all elites.

All Basic Economy passengers will receive Group 9 boarding, which is the very last group to board the aircraft. There is a high likelihood that overhead bin space will be full by this point, forcing you to gate check any bags to your final destination (at no cost other than your time picking it up when you arrive).

Outside of elite status or holding a designated AAdvantage credit card, there is no way to avoid this. Group 9 boarding really isn’t for the faint of heart — you’re forced to wait around the gate area until the very end, and when you board the plane, there simply won’t be storage room for any bags.

Seat Selection

Seat selection for Basic Economy passengers is based on available space and will be assigned at check in. Many Basic passengers will likely sit in middle seats, or undesirable “leftover” economy seats that others haven’t chosen.

Hot Tip: Basic passengers will be given the chance to purchase select seats 48 hours prior to departure, but this won’t include options for “Preferred” or Main Cabin Extra sections.

Some passengers have reported success in waiting until the last minute to check in, after all economy seats in the back have filled. Because of this, they’re assigned fairly decent seats in the front — in some cases even Main Cabin Extra seats — simply due to lack of availability elsewhere.

There is a risk, however: if you wait to check in without any seat assignment and there’s truly no seat to assign you, you could be involuntary denied boarding if the aircraft is oversold. Don’t wait if you really have to travel!

Upgrades

Here’s a huge kicker for a majority of elites: no paid or complimentary upgrades will be allowed as a Basic Economy passenger. To explain this a little more, there are 3 circumstances most customers fall into:

  • Option 1: You’re an AAdvantage elite on a Basic Economy domestic ticket. The cabin is wide open, but you will never clear into first class on a Basic ticket. I have heard rumors of some elites being offered first class seats after the entire list has been cleared or in cases of extra seats. But this is completely against policy and is not the norm — you shouldn’t expect or hope for any upgrade on a Basic fare.
  • Option 2: You’re on an international Basic Economy ticket, and upgrade space (C) has opened for your long-haul flight. But that doesn’t matter — you won’t be allowed to upgrade using any miles, copay, systemwide upgrade, or even an upgrade gifted to you if you are on a Basic Economy ticket.
  • Option 3: You are a regular passenger (no elite status) on a flight where the first class cabin is nearly empty, and there are no other elites to be upgraded. Normally, you would be offered a Load Factor Based Upgrade (LFBU) since all others have cleared and there is no waitlist. But as a Basic Economy customer, you will not be given this option.
American Airlines 777 300 ER
For a comfortable international business class flight, check out American Airlines’ 777-300ER. Image courtesy of aa.com.

Personally, this is probably the top reason I don’t purchase Basic Economy tickets. As an AAdvantage Executive Platinum, I value the complimentary upgrades with my status — because I have such a high upgrade percentage, it would almost be a waste of my status if I didn’t try to put in for the upgrade.

Even if I don’t seek an upgrade immediately, I always have the option of adding or requesting it later. But not on a Basic fare — I’d always end up in coach, no matter what.

Bottom Line: If you value upgrades, Basic Economy is simply not for you!

For more upgrade information, see our complete guide on how to get upgraded on American Airlines flights.

Rebooking

Should your plane experience any irregular operations — including because of weather or mechanical issues — you can be re-accommodated on American Airlines or joint-business partner airlines only. If you’re an AAdvantage elite, you’ll experience additional protection or re-booking options, including other alliance members (or other airlines in extreme cases).

If you book a Basic ticket, be cautious: your rebooking options may be limited depending on flight loads and origin/destination cities, while other passengers will have priority. For example, in the case of severe mechanical disruptions, American may decide to put qualifying passengers on United to get to their final destination. As a Basic Economy customer, you won’t have this option.

Elite Miles/Segments

As a final restriction, you’ll receive a reduced Elite Qualifying Mile (EQM) and Elite Qualifying Segments (EQS) rate. Basic Economy passengers will only receive .5 miles for every mile flown, and half a segment.

Be very cautious with this if you’re trying to attain AAdvantage elite status — since you’ll be earning half the miles and segments, it will take you DOUBLE the amount of time to complete status requirements. Imagine flying several thousands of miles to Europe, only to receive half of those miles eligible for any status qualification.

What Does Regular American Airlines Economy Include?

Just to compare offerings, it’s good to understand what the normal economy pricing includes so you can see both sides.

Baggage

Normal economy fares include a carry-on bag in the overhead bin and a personal item stored under the seat in front of you, the same as Basic Economy. Both Basic and regular passengers ,who don’t have status or an AAdvantage credit card, will have to pay for checked baggage. (We’ve covered AA baggage fees in-depth if you need more information.)

Ticket Changes

However, normal economy fares DO include options for same-day flight changes (usually for a fee) and the option to change travel completely for a $200 fee. Even with this $200 fee, you’ll still have flexibility in cases where plans get disrupted — generally businesspeople and large corporate accounts will book regular fares to have this option.

If you have a minor schedule irregularity or are seeking a fee waiver, you’d almost certainly need a regular fare to secure any changes. And note that many business travel accounts are programmed not to include Basic fares in search results due to these restrictions — so if you are in a corporate travel environment, check with your travel coordinator for more information.

Bottom Line: Same-day changes are one of the perks available with regular economy fares but not Basic Economy fares.

Economy Boarding & Priority Access

Priority Access is available for purchase on a regular economy ticket, and all elite levels will board with their respective groups: Executive Platinum in Group 2, Platinum Pro and Platinum in Group 3, and Gold in Group 4. AAdvantage credit card holders will board in Group 5 after all elites.

American Airlines plane
Image courtesy of Shutterstock.com

Economy Seat Selection

Seat selection is free to regular economy customers, but some preferred seats or Main Cabin Extra seats may come with an additional fee — in any case, all seats on the aircraft are available for selection/purchase at any time. Elites will be able to choose preferred or Main Cabin Extra seats at any time, unlike Basic Economy passengers, who can’t make any selections at all (without paying extra).

In my opinion, having access to these better seats is one of the reasons not to purchase Basic Economy fares, especially on longer flights where sitting in a middle seat would really be uncomfortable. Your assignment will depend on how full the flight is, but those who wait to get the auto seat assignments do receive undesirable middle seats (mostly at the rear of the cabin).

Regardless of ticket purchased, the actual seat types are the same — the physical seat won’t change, though some seats are certainly preferred thanks to location on the plane or increased legroom, for example. There is no designated “Basic Economy” seat section.

Upgrades

Paid and complimentary upgrades are allowed in regular economy, including complimentary domestic upgrades, miles and copay upgrades, systemwide upgrades, or load factor based upgrades (for elites and non-elites alike).

You can also pay to upgrade your fare from a regular economy ticket to a first class ticket without any additional change fee — something you certainly can’t do on a Basic fare. However, there are some reports of up-faring a Basic ticket to regular economy after purchase for those who didn’t realize they were booking Basic Economy (or the restrictions it would come with).

In this scenario, if you need to change your ticket from Basic to regular, call American reservations and they can assist in the process.

Rebooking

In case of irregular operations, there are several options available to regular economy or business/first passengers and those with elite status if delays exceed several hours:

  • All long-haul first class and transcontinental first class passengers can be put on non-partner airlines if it gets them to their destination faster than other options.
  • ConciergeKey, Executive Platinum, Oneworld Emerald, and Platinum Pro in all cabins can also be put on non-partner airlines if it will get them to their destination faster than other options.
  • Passengers in business and short-haul first class can be put on non-partner airlines if American and its partners can’t get them to their destination within 5 hours of the original schedule.
  • Platinum, Oneworld Sapphire, Gold, and Oneworld Ruby in all cabins can be put on non-partner airlines if American and its partners can’t get them to their destination within 5 hours of the original schedule.
  • If you have no status and are in economy, you can’t use partner airlines, but American will work to rebook you on their own flights.

As you can see, you’re already somewhat behind on a regular ticket as far as rebooking priority — so a Basic Economy fare would be severely restricting in these circumstances.

Elite Miles/Segments

Regular economy tickets earn the full amount of Elite Qualifying Miles (EQMs) and Elite Qualifying Segments (EQSs), not the half rate that Basic customers earn. I’ve often seen regular fares just a few dollars more than Basic fares, in which case it would definitely be better to purchase regular just for the full earning capability.

Bottom Line: If you want to earn elite status, it’s easier to do so on regular economy fares vs. Basic economy fares.

What About Basic Economy on Other Carriers?

In general, you can assume you’ll see similar treatment and logistics on Alaska, Delta, and United when it comes to Basic fares. All 3 carriers offer the ability to bring onboard carry-on bags, as well as the restriction to make changes to tickets, upgrade, or select any advance seat assignments without a fee.

For the most part, no airline wants to make their Basic Economy experience any worse than another airline, for fear that Basic customers will book elsewhere. This happened in 2018 when American restricted carry-on bags. Customers started choosing United and Delta instead, since they could see the difference when booking via online travel agencies.

Now, the carriers are essentially aligned in their benefits (or lack thereof), so their flights show up in all search results for these no-frill passengers. Let’s go through a quick comparison to help you decide:

  • If you’re concerned about selecting seats, both American and United auto-assign seats at check-in, while Delta allows you to choose your own seat at that time.
  • If you’re concerned about elite qualifying credit, both American and Delta award this credit, while United does not.
  • All carriers offer award miles.
  • None of the carries offer upgrades or ticket changes.

In the end, there’s really no “better” Basic Economy experience, so if you’re in for the no-frills ticket, purchase the best one for your needs.

Final Thoughts

Don’t let American’s Basic Economy experience scare you off — it certainly is a great product for those who don’t care about perks or amenities and are truly price-conscious. If this sounds like you, a Basic fare will more than likely suit you fine.

However, if you’re a business person, traveling in a corporate environment, or value additional extras like upgrades and seat selection, avoid the Basic experience in favor of regular economy.


Featured Image: Courtesy of Shutterstock.com

FAQ

What is Basic Economy?

Basic Economy is the most restrictive fare class on American Airlines, allowing the airline to compete with low cost carriers such as Frontier and Spirit by offering a now frills, amenity-less product.

What are the main restrictions of Basic Economy?

The main restrictions include inability to change the ticket, no seat assignments, no possibility of upgrade and half the amount of elite qualifying earnings.

James Larounis

About James Larounis

Jamie first got his hook on miles and points during a high school choir trip to Europe, where he flew in Lufthansa First Class (thanks to his dad’s then US Airways miles) because economy was sold out.

Disclaimer: Any comments listed below are not from the bank advertiser, nor have they been reviewed or approved by them. No responsibility will be taken by the bank advertiser for these comments.

5 comments

  1. Jennifer S. · June 16, 2019 · Reply

    This kind of information should make national news. I’m so angry at American for this basic economy – it’s a rub. It’s deceiving and they mean it to be if you ask me. I booked a “basic” economy flight with my brother who has CP. It wasn’t until after booking where I realized we couldn’t choose seats together. Now we are at the airline’s mercy – we cannot cancel or change.

    I used to travel with AA all the time – but they are becoming just like the other airlines. I have been on flights over and over again where I see families and elderly couples who are split up for the flight and put in the awkward situation of desperately asking if someone can trade seats. I think that is boo on the airline.

    Sure, people should be “buyer informed” but the way these airlines are messing with “cheap” fares and the ridiculous add-ons is just getting ridiculous! Even Southwest used to be the one you could count on, but now they have several tiers of add-ons also. So they are no better either.

    What does it matter if 2 people flying on “basic economy” together want to choose an economy seat sitting together?

    Hey, what if 2 people could fly affordably, without any gimmicks, and have a nice experience? Happy flyers?? What a concept!!

    • James Larounis · June 19, 2019 · Reply

      Hi Jennifer,

      The reason airline’s do not allow customers to sit together is because they want you to buy up to the regular Main Cabin product, and they place a monetary premium on you sitting together. Because most low cost airlines charge for seats, American is essentially presenting the option to either pay for those seats, or don’t pay for them, but risk not sitting together. American is trying to compete with the low cost carriers who offer a less inclusive service, and while this does seem deceiving to some travelers, American is required (and does) warn you about the differences between booking a Basic Economy product and regular Main Cabin product at booking. The good news here is that in most cases, American will allow you to buy out of Basic Economy – that is, pay the fare difference from Basic Economy to regular economy. From there, you can choose to sit together. To do this, you’d need to call American Airlines reservations. I hope this information helps.

    • I bought basic economy tickets for me and my 5 year old daughter from SMF to MCO about a week ago, and I was able to choose our seats at the time of purchase for no fee. I don’t know how or why, though I have elite gold status which could be the reason. But, the terms say no one booking basic economy can choose their seats, even if you have elite status. I’m not complaining or will call to inquire about it as I’m good with it, I just find it strange.

  2. I purchased an American Airlines basic economy ticket just a few weeks ago because the fare was so ridiculously low, I couldn’t pass it up. I was very nervous about it because I always get the main cabin with upgrades .
    Guess what came along ? A hurricane !!!! I couldn’t change my flight and I was just too worried about flying with a hurricane on the way . I cancelled the trip . I will never buy Basic Economy again…..even if the deal is too good to be true .

    • Christine Krzyszton · October 2, 2019 · Reply

      Hi Sunny. Sorry for your experience. Just to be clear, American Airlines does issue waivers for hurricanes and does not exclude basic economy tickets. The terms are stated when each waiver is issued. If you booked your trip with a credit card that carries trip interruption/cancellation/delay, you may also be able to find coverage there.

Any thoughts or questions? Comment below!

Email needed if you'd like comment updates. It will NOT be published.

Advertiser Disclosure

Many of the credit card offers that appear on this site are from credit card companies from which we receive financial compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear). However, the credit card information that we publish has been written by experts who know these products inside out, and what we recommend is what we would (or already) use ourselves. This site does not include all credit card companies or all available credit card offers that are on the market. For more information on our advertisers, see here.