The 23 Best Caribbean Hotels To Book With Points [For Max Value]

The Caribbean is an expansive and diverse region. One of the most convenient resort destinations to access from the U.S. East Coast, the tourism industry here has thrived and even exploded in recent years.

If you’re planning a leisure trip or a corporate retreat to the Caribbean, you’ll want to pay attention to the best luxury hotels and resorts available.

In this guide, we break down our favorite Caribbean hotels to book with points for maximum value. See the most popular territories first, then the best properties in destinations that weren’t covered.

Let’s get started!

The 4 Best Puerto Rico Hotels To Book With Points

1. The St. Regis Bahia Beach Resort, Puerto Rico (Marriott Bonvoy)

The St. Regis Bahia Beach Resort, Puerto Rico is an incredible property of pure opulence nestled at the beachfront of picturesque Puerto Rico. It’s next to El Yunque National Forest and on a 483-acre former coconut plantation.

Each of the boastful rooms is 674 square feet large with a private terrace and furnished with 1 king bed or 2 queen beds featuring 400-thread count bedding. You’ll also find an oversized desk, walk-in closet, and flat-screen TV. Help yourself to the honor bar, minifridge, and free Wi-Fi.

Within the marble bathroom, relax in the separate soaking bathtub and luxuriate with amenities by Remede, as well as slippers and bathrobes. The bathroom features a walk-in rain shower, water closet, and double vanity.

On-site, there is a Mediterranean restaurant serving fresh seafood, an alfresco oceanview restaurant, and a signature St. Regis Bar.

Relax with a full spa, fitness center, and multiple pools. Activities include a golf course, kids’ bar, tennis courts, bike rentals, kayaking, and yoga. You can also plan a wedding or event here!

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 70,000 to 100,000

Cash Rate: $825 to $3,000 ($1,100 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 3 cents per point

2. The Ritz-Carlton, San Juan (Marriott Bonvoy)

The Ritz-Carlton, San Juan competes fiercely with The St. Regis Bahia Beach Resort, though this property is closer to the airport and is located in the Greater San Juan area for maximum convenience. It’s just 5 miles from the Puerto Rico Museum of Contemporary Art, too.

Hot Tip: This property is still closed due to damage by Hurricane Maria. It’s scheduled to re-open in late 2024.

The glorious rooms each feature 1 king bed or 2 queen beds with 400-thread count Frette linens. Use the business desk and 3 in-room phones, and enjoy the fully-stocked bar, coffee and tea machine, and flat-screen TV.

The sumptuous marble bathrooms feature a single vanity, walk-in rain shower, separate soaking bathtub, and water closet. Asprey amenities, bathrobes, slippers, and a lighted makeup mirror add to your comfort.

On the premises (pre-hurricane), there were 5 restaurants, a cocktail bar, and a Club Lounge, all serving a variety of cuisines.

There was also a gym, 12,000-square-foot spa, an outdoor pool, and private beach access. The casino, tennis courts, business center, and a Ritz-Carlton boutique were also available for guests. Even the ballroom was grand, measuring nearly 12,000 square feet large!

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 70,000 to 100,000

Cash Rate: N/A (property is still closed)

Points Value: N/A (property is still closed)

3. Hyatt Regency Grand Reserve Puerto Rico (World of Hyatt)

The Hyatt Regency Grand Reserve Puerto Rico is a 5-star complex is located on a beach along the North Atlantic Ocean. It’s 8 miles from the El Yunque National Forest and 22 miles from Luis Muñoz Marin Airport (SJU).

There are 579 rooms and suites, and the standard rooms have garden views with 520 square feet of space. You have the option of selecting 1 king bed or 2 double beds, and each room features a Cozy Corner with a sleeper sofa. You’ll also enjoy a flat-screen TV, furnished patio, coffee machine, and minifridge.

Additionally, the bathroom consists of a single vanity, an oversized walk-in rain shower, posh amenities, a hairdryer, and a backlit LED mirror.

Restaurant options include an extensive buffet, a Japanese teppanyaki restaurant, sushi bar, prime steakhouse, poolside tacos, Regency Club Lounge, an upscale Puerto Rican restaurant, and more.

You’ll also find 2 18-hole golf courses, a full fitness center, spa, and 30,000+ square feet of meeting and event space. Swimming options abound with a lagoon pool and private beach access.

Category: 5

World of Hyatt Points Required: 17,000 to 23,000

Cash Rate: $240 to $900 ($450 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 5 cents per point

4. La Concha Renaissance San Juan Resort (Marriott Bonvoy)

The last property to discuss in Puerto Rico is La Concha Renaissance San Juan Resort, which boasts 4-star luxury just steps from the famous Condado Beach.

You can pick between 1 king bed or 2 double beds with entry-level rooms measuring around 396 square feet large. The furnishings are modern and the décor is bright with high ceilings; room amenities include coffee and tea facilities, a desk, flat-screen TV, minifridge, an iPod dock, and more.

Inside the bathroom, you’ll find a walk-in rain shower, single vanity, lighted makeup mirror, bathrobes, and hairdryer.

Dining options are eightfold, ranging from upscale Italian cuisine to quick grab-and-go choices.

The resort has a casino open 24/7, 2 outdoor pools, and a gym, as well as meeting and event space.

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 40,000 to 60,000

Cash Rate: $350 to $1,100 ($400 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 1.8 cents per point

Bottom Line: For even more options, check out these additional Puerto Rico hotels that you can book with points.

The 3 Best Turks and Caicos Hotels To Book With Points

1. Sailrock Resort (World of Hyatt)

What better way to enjoy a secluded vacation in the magical Turks and Caicos than a stay at the famous Sailrock Resort? This high-end property is 4 miles from the South Caicos Airport (XSC) and 5 miles from Cockburn Harbour.

This small, remote island retreat has just 36 suites and villas, each airy and incredibly comfortable. The standard suites each measure 506 square feet and have a glorious 382-square-foot wraparound terrace with envious views.

Beyond that, you’ll find a king-sized bed and sitting area with a couch. Each room features a flat-screen TV, set of coffee and tea facilities, kitchenette, wet bar, and free Wi-Fi.

Within the bathroom, you’ll find a separate deep-soaking bathtub and an oversized walk-in rain shower. Each bathroom features a twin vanity, water closet, and signature bath and body products.

A complimentary airport shuttle, as well as breakfast and welcome drinks, are yours when you stay here. You’ll find 2 restaurants and bars, a spa, and an outdoor pool. Stay active with the fitness center, outdoor yoga deck, and complimentary non-motorized water sports.

Category: 8

World of Hyatt Points Required: 35,000 to 45,000

Cash Rate: $525 to $2,700 ($900 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 6 cents per point

2. Point Grace Resort and Spa (World of Hyatt)

Point Grace Resort and Spa is an all-suite, boutique luxury hotel on the prestigious Grace Bay beachfront, which extends 12 miles. It’s also just 6 miles from the major international airport Providenciales (PLS), making it an accessible yet private getaway.

The standard room is 1,080 square feet large and situated on the ground level with a king bed, kitchenette, and furnished terrace. Within the room, find a desk, flat-screen LCD TV, and free Wi-Fi.

The bathroom contains a soaking bathtub, double vanity, separate shower, and high-end toiletries.

There are 2 dining options — a casual, open-air tropical eatery and a signature restaurant with French-inspired options and picturesque outdoor seating.

This property also includes an outdoor pool with a poolside bar, fitness center, lavish spa, watersports center, and plenty of event space.

Category: 8

World of Hyatt Points Required: 35,000 to 45,000

Cash Rate: $600 to $2,750 ($800 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 6 cents per point

3. The Ritz-Carlton, Turks & Caicos (Marriott Bonvoy)

The last Turks and Caicos resort we’ll discuss is the new Ritz-Carlton, Turks & Caicos, which opened in June of 2021. This resort is set on Grace Bay, one of the best beaches in the area.

Each standard room is 442 square feet large and has panoramic oceanfront views with a private furnished balcony, 1 king bed or 2 double beds, an informal dining table, and a chaise lounge. You’ll also find a flat-screen TV and a Nespresso coffee machine.

Within the luxe marble bathroom, you’ll find a walk-in rain shower, separate, deep-soaking bathtub, and double vanity. Find comfort with terry cloth bathrobes, slippers, Asprey products, and a lighted makeup mirror.

High-end cuisine options dot the property, ranging from an American steakhouse to a Mediterranean restaurant, as well as an Italian trattoria and a lobby lounge serving sushi and cocktails.

Enjoy a spa treatment, go scuba diving, or rejuvenate at either of the 2 outdoor pools. Beachside cabana rentals are available for an added fee, as are motorized watersports (non-motorized watersports are complimentary). Lastly, the gym, casino, and kids’ club are state-of-the-art, along with the preeminent meeting spaces.

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 70,000 to 100,000

Cash Rate: $800 to $2,800 ($1,400 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 2.8 cents per point

The 4 Best Aruba Hotels To Book With Points

1. The Ritz-Carlton, Aruba (Marriott Bonvoy)

Aruba’s most iconic luxury hotel is The Ritz-Carlton, Aruba. It offers virtually everything you could ask for when traveling to the Caribbean island. Just 8 miles from the airport and downtown Oranjestad, this Palm Beach property oozes pure luxury.

To start, every room has 550 square feet of space, including a comfortable king bed, furnished balcony, and sitting area with a couch. Each room features a work desk, flat-screen TV, minibar, and Nespresso machine.

In addition, the bathrooms have a double vanity, walk-in rain shower, and an oversized soaking bathtub. Pamper yourself with robes, slippers, and Asprey bath and body products.

This resort has 6 dining options, a 24/7 casino with live entertainment, Club Lounge, 15,000-square-foot spa, salon, shopping boutique, and soaring meeting spaces.

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 70,000 to 100,000

Cash Rate: $800 to $4,600 ($1,400 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 4.6 cents per point

2. Hyatt Regency Aruba Resort Spa and Casino (World of Hyatt)

Another excellent-value property is the Hyatt Regency Aruba Resort Spa and Casino, our go-to World of Hyatt property in Aruba. It’s set on Palm Beach and is 4 miles from the Aloe Museum and 4 miles from California Lighthouse.

You’ll find each standard room is 380 square feet large, has a balcony and 1 king bed or 2 queen beds, and is conveniently located to the resort’s facilities. Within each room, you’ll find a daybed, lounge chair, flat-screen TV, minifridge, coffee machine with Starbucks pods, Tazo tea, and desk.

Furthermore, the brightly lit bathrooms have a single vanity, shower-tub combination, and makeup mirror, and feature Pharmacopia Natural Body Care products.

When you stay here, you can relax and unwind, whether it’s at the 9 bars and restaurants, white-sand beaches, 8,000-square-foot activity pool, or yoga on the beach. Stay and play at the enormous casino, tennis courts, or kids’ camp.

Category: 7

World of Hyatt Points Required: 25,000 to 35,000

Cash Rate: $600 to $1,800 ($850 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 6.2 cents per point

3. Aruba Marriott Resort & Stellaris Casino (Marriott Bonvoy)

Another popular resort, especially among U.S. travelers, is the Aruba Marriott Resort & Stellaris Casino, which is a beachfront property offering entertainment and relaxation.

Sink your head into a room with a king bed or 2 queen beds and enjoy the 400 square feet of indoor space or 100 square feet of furnished, outdoor balcony space with soundproof windows.

You’ll also notice a walk-in closet, sitting area with a couch and lounge chair, desk, set of coffee and tea machines, and a flat-screen TV with premium channels.

The bathroom contains a double vanity, shower-tub combination, lighted makeup mirror and vanity, bathrobes, and slippers.

At this hotel, you will find a Ruth’s Chris Steak House, seafood restaurant, beach bar and grill, lobby and gelato bar, an all-day international restaurant, and adults-only poolside cocktail bar.

In addition to the restaurants, you’ll find a full-service spa with a sauna and a hot tub, a 24/7 casino, and an abundance of meeting space. Enjoy private beach access, an adults-only pool, a family pool, and a gym.

AVerage Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 50,000 to 70,000

Cash Rate: $530 to $2,000 ($900 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 2.9 cents per point

4. Hilton Aruba Caribbean Resort & Casino (Hilton Honors)

Our final Aruba hotel is the Hilton Aruba Caribbean Resort & Casino, colloquially referred to as the Hilton Aruba. This expansive resort sits 2.5 miles from Divi Village Golf Course and 7 miles from the international airport.

Each standard room has 1 king bed, 2 double beds, or 2 queen beds in it, along with a private balcony or patio and garden and tropical views. Room amenities include a flat-screen TV, minifridge, coffee machine, and desk.

The bathrooms are appointed with an oversized walk-in shower and single vanity. Relax with bathrobes, slippers, and Signature Pasada Coco Aloe amenities.

As far as dining options go, you can pick from a sunset grill restaurant, seafood spot, grab-and-go Lavazza coffee shop, poolside cocktail bar with live music and a happy hour, an all-day restaurant, and another refreshing cocktail bar.

Things to do here include relaxing on the white-sand beaches or sending the little ones to the kids’ club and retreating to the spa. Play at the casino, check out the 2 outdoor pools, or host an event at the ballroom.

Hilton Honors Points Required: 80,000

Cash Rate: $250 to $1,400 ($550 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 1.8 cents per point

The 3 Best Dominican Republic Hotels To Book With Points

1. Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana (World of Hyatt)

The Dominican Republic is famous for its all-inclusive resorts, and World of Hyatt has 2 of the most luxurious choices in the country.

The Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana is less than 10 miles from the international airport and placed along the Caribbean Sea’s white-sand beaches. This is an adults-only resort with rave reviews.

This sprawling resort has 375 suites, each with at least 600 square feet of space, a king bed or 2 double beds, and a furnished balcony. Find a sofa, desk, flat-screen TV, minibar, and coffee and tea machines in each room.

In the bathrooms, you’ll find a walk-in shower, bathtub, makeup vanity, and double vanity, as well as bathrobes and slippers.

You won’t ever have to leave this property during your stay because there are a whopping 25 restaurants and bars, a water park with a lazy river and waterslides, infinity pools, and a world-class gym. Get easy access to championship golf courses, a spa, live entertainment, and plenty of included daily activities.

Pool cabana rentals, spa treatments, and private dining are extra, as are meeting and event space rentals.

World of Hyatt Points Required: 35,000 to 45,000 for double occupancy (10,500 to 14,500 points per night for each additional guest; maximum of 4 people per room)

Cash Rate: $425 to $1,100 ($750 on average) per night, based on double occupancy

Points Value: Up to 3.8 cents per point, based on double occupancy

2. Hyatt Ziva Cap Cana (World of Hyatt)

The Hyatt Ziva Cap Cana is the family-friendly equivalent of the Hyatt Zilara Cap Cana — the 2 properties are right next to each other! This Juanillo Beach property has plenty of amenities for the whole family to enjoy.

The junior suites start at 600 square feet in size and have a furnished balcony or patio, 1 king bed or 2 queen beds, plus a queen-sized sleeper sofa in both arrangements.

You’ll also find a work desk, lounge chair, crisp flat-screen TV, minibar, and coffee and tea facilities.

Additionally, check out the modern bathroom with double sinks, a walk-in rainfall shower, bathrobes, slippers, and upscale toiletries.

In total, the resort has 14 dining options, as well as private dining and 24/7 room service. Most of your daily activities are included, including water sports, pool access, and a 14,000-square-foot gym with classes. There’s a kids’ club, live entertainment, dance classes, VR experiences, and more.

World of Hyatt Points Required: 35,000 to 45,000 for double occupancy (10,500 to 14,500 points per night for each additional guest; maximum of 4 people per room)

Cash Rate: $400 to $1,300 ($550 on average) per night, based on double occupancy

Points Value: Up to 4.5 cents per point, based on double occupancy

Hot Tip: Curious about Ziva and Zilara properties? Check out our guides to the Hyatt Ziva and Hyatt Zilara brands.

3. Hilton La Romana, an All-Inclusive Adult Only Resort (Hilton Honors)

Hilton La Romana Resort, an All-Inclusive Adult Only Resort is a newly renovated oasis offering a familiar brand name and a polished experience.

This resort is set along Bayahibe Beach and is 5 miles from the Cueva de Chicho caves and a little over 40 miles from the international airport.

The standard rooms measure 411 square feet in size and come with 2 double beds or 1 king bed and either a furnished balcony or terrace, plus garden views. Rooms feature a minibar, flat-screen TV with premium channels, and an indoor sitting area with 2 dining chairs.

In the bathroom, you’ll find a single vanity, walk-in rain shower, soaking tub, wall-mounted lighted makeup mirror, and Crabtree & Evelyn amenities.

Savor 10 dining options and engage in a selection of activities including windsurfing, snorkeling, volleyball, spa treatments, or taking a swim at any of the 3 outdoor pools. There’s also a casino, gym, private beach access, and event or meeting space.

Hilton Honors Points Required: 63,000 to 80,000

Cash Rate: $275 to $1,000 ($600 on average) per night, based on double occupancy

Points Value: Up to 1.3 cents per point

Hot Tip: Those traveling with kids may enjoy the neighboring Hilton La Romana, an All-Inclusive Family Resort.

The 3 Best Jamaica Hotels To Book With Points

1. The Trident Hotel (World of Hyatt)

The Trident Hotel is a favorite among the Upgraded Points team because of its high-end exclusivity and its seductive location amidst a busy Port Antonio.

Jamaica’s most elite luxury resort is surrounded by azure blue waters and the jungle, making this one of the country’s best-kept secrets, tucked away from the hustle and bustle of tourism.

There are just 13 private villas here. Yes, you saw that right. Only 13 villas! The standard villa, known as the Studio Villa, is a whopping 1,722 square feet in size, including the 1,100-square-foot outdoor terrace with a landscaped lawn, sun loungers, and ocean views. There’s also a king-sized bed, spacious living room, walk-in closet, wet bar, minibar, and flat-screen TV.

The bathroom consists of a single vanity, separate rain shower, an outdoor deep-soaking bathtub, bathrobes, and slippers.

The unique dining options include a Cabaret lounge and 2 full-service restaurants. As you make your way through the property, make a stop at the spa, salon, gym, beach, business center, or event facilities.

Category: 7

World of Hyatt Points Required: 25,000 to 35,000

Cash Rate: $500 to $1,800 ($700 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 4 cents per point

2. Hyatt Ziva Rose Hall (World of Hyatt)

Hyatt Ziva Rose Hall is just 7 miles from the international airport, making it easier than ever to access all-inclusive luxury in Jamaica; it’s also just 3 miles from the White Witch Golf Course and a little more than a mile from Rose Hall mansion. Hyatt Ziva is family-friendly, while Hyatt Zilara (discussed next) is adults-only.

This expansive, family-friendly resort has 277 rooms and suites, each at least 493 square feet large with a furnished terrace, king bed or 2 double beds, plus a queen sleeper sofa, and desk. Rooms feature a minibar, flat-screen TV, and coffee machine.

In the bathroom, you’ll find designer toiletries, plus a walk-in shower, single vanity bathrobes, and slippers.

Unlimited food and beverages (including alcoholic beverages) can be enjoyed at any of the 11 restaurants and bars. Oh, and 24/7 room service is included, too.

Additionally, there are 2 outdoor pools, 2 whirlpools, a spa, fitness center, watersports center, kids’ club, and meeting or event space.

World of Hyatt Points Required: 25,000 to 35,000 for double occupancy (13,000 to 17,000 points per night for each additional guest; maximum of 4 people per room)

Cash Rate: $300 to $800 ($400 on average) per night, based on double occupancy

Points Value: Up to 2.8 cents per point, based on double occupancy

3. Hyatt Zilara Rose Hall (World of Hyatt)

The adults-only sister resort Hyatt Zilara Rose Hall is a romantic luxury retreat around 33 miles away from Hyatt Ziva Rose Hall. This property is closer to the international airport, just a short 10-minute drive away.

Each king or double bedroom has 493 square feet with a furnished terrace and sitting area with a couch. Amenities include a work desk, coffee machine, minibar, and flat-screen TV.

The marble bathrooms are outfitted with a double vanity, deep soaking bathtub, wall-mounted makeup mirror, rain shower, and water closet, along with bathrobes and slippers.

17 food and beverage options exist here, as well as private dining and 24-hour room service.

You’ll also find 3 outdoor pools, water sports, a fitness center with an aqua gym, and a full spa. Stay entertained with daily activities, music and live entertainment, and easy access to 2 par-71 golf courses. Direct beach access is a given here.

World of Hyatt Points Required: 25,000 to 35,000 for double occupancy (13,000 to 17,000 points per night for each additional guest; maximum of 4 people per room)

Cash Rate: $350 to $1,000 ($550 on average) per night, based on double occupancy

Points Value: Up to 3.4 cents per point, based on double occupancy

The 3 Best Bahamas Hotels To Book With Points

1. French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection (Marriott Bonvoy)

The most underrated Marriott Bonvoy property in the Caribbean is French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection. This incredible villa-only property is surrounded by the jungle and overlooks the chic Governor’s Harbour.

It’s just an 11-minute walk from the town center’s restaurants, a little over a mile from French Leave Beach, and 8 miles from the airport.

This pricey resort’s standard villa features a Colonial-era vibe and has harbor views, partial ocean views, a plush king bed, and 720 square feet of personal space. Features include a flat-screen TV, minibar, and coffee and tea facilities.

The bathrooms have a walk-in rain shower, lighted makeup mirror, single vanity, hairdryer, bathrobes, and L’Occitane bath amenities.

You’ll find 1 full-service restaurant and bar, plus an infinity pool, whirlpool, and gym. Get in the water with water sports and a marina with 5 moorings.

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 70,000 to 100,000

Cash Rate: $600 to $1,350 ($750 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 1.35 cents per point

2. The Cove at Atlantis (Marriott Bonvoy)

Part of the Atlantis Bahamas complex, The Cove at Atlantis is the most upscale property there, just 13 miles from the international airport in Nassau (NAS).

This lavish resort has standard rooms with 1 king bed or 2 queen beds, each with at least 672 square feet of space and generous furnishings, including a walk-in closet, living area, sleeper sofa bed, and balcony. Amenities include a desk, flat-screen TV, and coffee and tea.

The spa-like marble bathroom features twin granite vanities, vessel sinks, marble flooring, a deep-soaking bathtub, and a frosted, glass-tile enclosed rain shower. Pamper yourself with bathrobes, slippers, and a lighted makeup mirror.

Foodies rejoice here and choose from 30 restaurants and bars, including an outpost of New York-favorite Carmine’s, a Nobu location, and a seafood restaurant by José Andrés.

The resort’s amenities are incredible, including a fitness area, cinema, spa, and even a casino! Enjoy the water with numerous outdoor pools, a water theme park, direct beach access, marine exhibits, and fish feedings.

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 70,000 to 100,000

Cash Rate: $500 to $2,600 ($750 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 2.6 cents per point

3. Grand Hyatt Baha Mar (World of Hyatt)

Our last property is an equally impressive complex of facilities and buildings known as Grand Hyatt Baha Mar. This property is just 6 miles from Nassau International Airport (NAS) and has a private beach on the Atlantic Ocean.

This gigantic resort has 1,800 rooms and suites, and the standard rooms measure at least 382-square-feet large. Floor-to-ceiling windows brighten up the room, and there’s a Juliet balcony, as well as a king bed or 2 queen beds and views of the nightly fountain shower. Use your personal, in-room tablet with resort information and games, flat-screen TV, and Keurig coffee and tea machine.

The luxurious marble bathroom has a soaking bathtub, separate rain shower, water closet, and twin vanities. Clean up with a wall-mounted, lighted makeup mirror, Balmain amenities, bathrobes, and slippers.

You’ll find a whopping 30 food and beverage options and extensive entertainment. Visit the resort’s cigar lounge, art gallery, spa, casino, and tons of event space. Or stay active with 6 outdoor pools, an 18-hole golf course, tennis courts, a full gym, and a watersports center. This property is not lacking in amenities.

Category: 6

World of Hyatt Points Required: 21,000 to 29,000

Cash Rate: $450 to $1,100 ($500 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 4.8 cents per point

The 3 Best Other Caribbean Hotels To Book With Points

Now that we’ve wrapped up discussing the best hotels in specific countries or territories, let’s take a walk through some of the best “other” Caribbean hotels, all of which are destination properties in and of themselves.

1. Park Hyatt St. Kitts Christophe Harbour (World of Hyatt)

One of the newer additions to the Park Hyatt portfolio, the Park Hyatt St. Kitts Christophe Harbour is one of those places where you can truly rewind on the property without leaving.

This property is a little more than a mile from Great Salt Pond, 7 miles from Royal Beach Casino, and 8 miles from Royal St. Kitts Golf Club. If you need access to other amenities, it’s just a short drive away.

Each chic room contains a private balcony or patio, as well as 527 square feet of space, a daybed, desk, and an espresso machine.

The spa bathroom contains a deep-soaking bathtub, double vanity, and walk-in rain shower, along with a lighted makeup mirror, bathrobes, slippers, and luxe bath products. Also, there’s a separate powder room with a toilet and sink.

Dining options can be anywhere between upscale fine-dining or laid-back beachfront fare. There are also 2 outdoor pools, a gym, a spa, and meeting or event space.

Category: 7

World of Hyatt Points Required: 25,000 to 35,000

Cash Rate: $600 to $1,800 ($1,100 on average) per night)

Points Value: Up to 5.1 cents per point

2. The Ritz-Carlton, St. Thomas (Marriott Bonvoy)

The Ritz-Carlton, St. Thomas rounds out our rankings of the household luxury hotel brand — it beats out competitors like The Ritz-Carlton, Grand Cayman because the property is generally thought to be in better condition than its Caribbean peers.

Each of the opulent rooms has 450 square feet of space, lush resort views, a private terrace, and high-end bedding. Amenities include a desk, flat-screen TV, minibar, and a Nespresso machine.

You’ll also find a marble bathroom boasting a separate soaking tub, a walk-in rain shower, double sinks, and a lighted makeup mirror with Asprey bath and body products, bathrobes, and slippers.

There are 5 dining options available here. Property amenities include a spa, gym, 2 pools, a waterslide, watersports, 2 tennis courts, a kids’ club, and event space.

Average Marriott Bonvoy Points Required: 70,000 to 100,000

Cash Rate: $900 to $3,200 ($1,100 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 3.2 cents per point

3. Zemi Beach House, LXR Hotels & Resorts (Hilton Honors)

The very last (but not least!) property in this guide is Zemi Beach House, LXR Hotels & Resorts, which belongs to the Hilton Honors loyalty program.

This property is less than 10 miles from a ferry terminal in Anguilla for seamless logistics.

This exotic boutique hotel comes with standard guestrooms that include 600 to 700 square feet of space, 1 king bed or 2 queen beds, a furnished balcony, and a sitting area. Each room has a desk, flat-screen HD TV, minibar, and an espresso machine.

The spa bathroom has a separate rain shower, soaking bathtub, double vanity, and high-end toiletries.

In total, there are 5 food and beverage outlets. You can also visit the spa, tennis court, gym, Turkish hammam, shopping boutique, or kids’ club. Get in the water with 4 outdoor pools (1 of which is an infinity pool) and world-class beach access. There’s also plenty of space for events.

Hilton Honors Points Required: 95,000

Cash Rate: $775 to $2,500 ($900 on average) per night

Points Value: Up to 2.6 cents per point

How To Earn Hotel Points To Redeem in the Caribbean

With all of these properties in mind, let’s now talk about the various ways you can accumulate enough hotel points to book your stay in the Caribbean.

At a high level, there are 3 main loyalty programs to focus on for the properties above: World of Hyatt, Marriott Bonvoy, and Hilton Honors.

Hot Tip: There are plenty of hotels in the Caribbean that fall under the IHG One Rewards or Wyndham Rewards portfolio, but the value you will get from each redemption usually pales in comparison to the “Big 3.” 

World of Hyatt

The singular best way to earn World of Hyatt points is by transferring them from Chase since the program is a Chase transfer partner at a 1:1 ratio.

That’s because you can easily earn lots of Ultimate Rewards points on everyday spending, which can then be transferred over to World of Hyatt instantly.

Recommended Chase Cards

In addition, The World of Hyatt Credit Card (issued by Chase) allows you to earn up to 9x points per $1 spent at Hyatt hotels, as well as 2x points per $1 spent at restaurants, on airline tickets purchased directly from the airline, gym and fitness club memberships, and local transit/commuting purchases.

On all other purchases, you’ll earn 1x point per $1.

Have a small business? You can also consider applying for the World of Hyatt Business Credit Card!

Hilton Honors

American Express is the sole issuer of Hilton co-branded credit card products, and it’s super easy to earn up to 14x Hilton Honors points per dollar spent at Hilton hotels!

Beyond that, though, another excellent way to earn Hilton Honors points is to transfer Amex points at a 1:2 ratio.

Recommended American Express Cards

Marriott Bonvoy

Marriott Bonvoy has a variety of credit card products issued by both American Express and Chase.

With the right Marriott Bonvoy credit card, you can earn Marriott Bonvoy points quickly (up to 17x points per $1 spent at Marriott properties), in addition to elite status and free night certificate benefits.

Recommended Marriott Bonvoy Cards

Marriott Bonvoy is also a 1:1 transfer partner with both Chase Ultimate Rewards and American Express Membership Rewards, but we do not recommend transferring points from these currencies unless you are just short a few thousand points for a specific redemption you have in mind.

Final Thoughts

When booking a stay at a hotel in the Caribbean, consider booking stays at any of the highest-value luxury properties in this guide.

We focused on the World of Hyatt, Marriott Bonvoy, and Hilton Honors chains because these properties are the easiest to get tons of value from.

From high-end Ritz-Carlton hotels to all-inclusive Hyatt Ziva or Hyatt Zilara resorts, you’ll have tons of options! Now, the next step is to book that stay!

For something a little different, check out these boutique hotels in the Caribbean.